Re-Thinking Models of Judicial Appointments in the Superior Courts of Pakistan: A Quest for a Better Model
Purpose: Since the inception of the notions of separation of powers and judicial independence, different judicial systems across the globe have devised various models of judicial appointments to meet the standards of the concepts of separation of powers and judicial independence.
Methodology: In general, three moles of judicial appointments namely the politicised, the judicialised and the institutionalised models have been used in different jurisdictions.
Findings: In Pakistan, since its independence, all these three models have been practiced, however none of these could help to achieve the required standards of judicial independence. The causes of failure perhaps rooted in the attitudes and intentions of the constitutional players rather than internal flaws of these three models.
Implications: This article analyses the pros and cons of these models of judicial appointments and the causes of failure of these models in provision of independent and trustworthy judiciary in Pakistan and then proposes a better model with further improvements for judicial appointments in Pakistan.
Article Analytics Summary
"Supreme Court Decision Undermines Legislature" (The Express Tribune, March 5, 2011).
Ahmed, Imran. 2017. "‘Strategic Constitutions’: Constitutional Change and Politics in Pakistan." South Asia: Journal of South Asian Studies 40 (3): 481-499.
Ali, Rafia Naz, and Mohammad Jan. 2018. "Critical Analysis of the Role of Democratic Institutions in the Appointment of Judges of Superior Courts in Pakistan." Journal of Law & Socie'y 49 (73): 51-62.
Al-Jehad Trust v Federation of Pakistan, PLD 1996 SC 324.
Al-Jehad Trust v Federation of Pakistan, PLD 1997 SC 84.
Almeida, Cyril. 2010. "Breathing room" Dawn, October 22.
Asad Ali v Federation of Pakistan, PLD 1998 SC 161.
Bell, J. 2003. "Judicial Appointments: some European experiences."Conference on" Judicial Reform: Function, Appointment and Model.
Blue, Richard, Richard Hoffman and Louis-Alexandre Berg. 2008. Pakistan Rule of Law Assessment – Final Report. USAID. <http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PNADO130.pdf>.
Bray, John. 1997. "Pakistan at 50: a state in decline?." International Affairs 73 (2): 315-331.
Bühlmann, Marc, and Ruth Kunz. 2011. "Confidence in the judiciary: Comparing the independence and legitimacy of judicial systems." West European Politics 34 (2): 317-345.
Cameron, Edwin. 1990. "Judicial accountability in South Africa." South African Journal on Human Rights 6 (2): 251-265.
Cheema, Moeen H. 2015. "The Chaudhry Court: Rule of Law or Judicialization of Politics." in The Politics and Jurisprudence of the Chaudhry Court 2005-20013, edited by Moeen Cheema and Ijaz Gilani, 197. Karachi: Oxford University Press.
Cheema, Moeen H. 2016. "The" Chaudhry Court": Deconstructing the" Judicialization of Politics" in Pakistan." Washington International Law Journal 25 (3): 447-487.
Cheema, Moeen H. 2018. "Two steps forward one step back: The non-linear expansion of judicial power in Pakistan." International Journal of Constitutional Law 16 (2): 503-526.
Clarke, Anthony Peter. 2009. Selecting Judges: Merit, Moral Courage, Judgment and Diversity." High Court Quarterly Review 5 (2): 49.
Constitution (Eighteenth Amendment) Act, 2010.
Constitution (Nineteenth Amendment) Act, 2010.
Constitution of Malaysia.
Constitution of Pakistan 1956.
Constitution of Pakistan 1962.
Constitution of Pakistan 1973.
Cotran, Eugene, and Martin Lau. 2008. Yearbook of Islamic and Middle Eastern Law. Eds. Victor Kattan, and Chibli Mallat: Brill Academic Publishers.
DCA (Department for Constitutional Affairs) 2003. Constitutional Reform: A New Way of Appointing Judges (Consultation Paper, CP10/03,) <http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20100512160448/dca.gov.uk/consult/jacommission/judges.pdf>.
Dhawan, Prannv. 2020. "'Reform That You May Preserve': Rethinking the Judicial Appointments Conundrum." Indian Journal of Constitutional Law 9: 186-196.
EAJ (European Association of Judges) 1997. Judges’ Charter in Europe.
Evans, Simon, and John Williams. 2008. "Appointing Australian judges: A new model." Sydney Law Review 30: 295.
Garoupa, Nuno, and Tom Ginsburg. 2009. "Guarding the guardians: Judicial councils and judicial independence." The American Journal of Comparative Law 57 (1): 103-134.
Gee, Graham. 2012. "The Persistent Politics of Judicial Selection: A Comparative Analysis." Judicial Independence in Transition: 121-145.
Gee, Graham. 2017. "Judging the JAC: How Much Judicial Influence Over Judicial Appointments Is Too Much?." In Debating Judicial Appointments in an Age of Diversity, edited by Graham Gee and Erica Rackley, 152-182. Routledge.
Gibbs, Sir Harry. 1987. "The Appointment and Removal of Judges." Federal Law Review 17 (3): 141-150.
Gill, Rebecca D. 2012. "A Framework for Comparative Judicial Selection Research With an Application to Gender Diversity on High Courts." Available at SSRN 1982705.
Goldschmidt, Jona, David Olson, and Margaret Ekman. 2008. "Relationship between Method of Judicial Selection and Judicial Misconduct." Widener Law Journal 18: 455.
Government of India Act 1935
Habib, Rao Imran and Mahdi Zahraa. 2012. "Judicial Independence in Pakistan: A Brief Historical Account" Harvard Asia Quarterly 14(3): 25-31.
Haq, Ijaz Ul. 2010. "Who is Supreme?" The News International, May 19.
Haq, Noor Ul. 2011. Eighteenth Amendment to the 1973 Constitution, IPRI Publications <http://ipripak.org/factfiles/ff134.pdf>.
Hashmi, Zeeshaan Zafar. 2018. "Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments or Amending the Unamendable: A Critique of District Bar Association Rawalpindi v. Federation of Pakistan." Pakistan Law Review 9: 1-49.
Hassan, Ahamd. "Parties strike accord on 18th Amendment" (Dawn, April 01, 2010). <http://www.dawn.com/news/528244/parties-strike-accord-on-18th-amendment>.
Hassan, Parvez. 2007. "Environmental Protection, Rule of Law and the Judicial Crisis in Pakistan." Asia Pacific Journal of. Environmental Law 10 (3&4): 167.
Hayo, Bernd, and Stefan Voigt. 2014. "Mapping constitutionally safeguarded judicial independence—A global survey." Journal of Empirical Legal Studies 11 (1): 159-195.
Hussain, F. 2011. The Judicial System of Pakistan (Supreme Court of Pakistan) <http://www.supremecourt.gov.pk/web/user_files/File/thejudicialsystemofPakistan.pdf>.
Hussain, Fayyaz Ahmad, and Abdul Basit Khan. 2012. "Role of the Supreme Court in the Constitutional and Political Development of Pakistan: History and Prospects." Journal of Politics and Law 5 (2): 82.
Hussain, Mahboob, and Rizwan Ullah Kokab. 2012. "Eighteenth Amendment in the Constitution of Pakistan: Success and Controversies." Asian Social Science 8 (1): 81.
IBA (International Bar Association). 2008. The Rule of Law and Human Rights in the Legal System of Pakistan. Report. <https://www.ibanet.org/Document/Default.aspx?DocumentUid=cccdd2a5-4943-4519-9c09-a131596bdd3c>.
Ibrahim, Fakhruddin G. 2010. ‘Pakistan: Again a Judicial Crisis – Not a Bonafide Crisis but a Crisis Created for Ulterior Reasons’. Asian Human Rights Commission http://www.humanrights.asia/document-type/forwarded-article/page/19/ .
ICG (International Crisis Group). 2004. Building Judicial Independence in Pakistan. Asia Report No 86. <https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/28401/086_building_judicial_independence_in_pakistan.pdf>.
Independence Act 1947.
Iqbal, Anees. 2012. "The Process of Judicial Appointments in Pakistan under the 1973 Constitution." The Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences 20 (1): 15-28.
Iqbal, Nasir. 2010. "Parliament doesn`t have unfettered powers: CJ." Dawn, August 17.
Iqbal, Nasir. 2010. "Parliament not under trial, says CJ." Dawn, July 28.
Jackson, Vicki C. 2012. "Judicial Independence: Model, Context, Attitude" in Judicial Independence in Transition, edited by Anja Seibert-Fohr, 19-86. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer.
Jowell, Jeffrey. 2010. "The Growing International Consensus in Favour of Independent Judicial Appointment Commissions." Judicial Appointments: Balancing Independence, Accountability and Legitimacy. <http://www.keithetherington.co.uk/downloads/files/JA_web.pdf >.
Kalhan, Anil. 2013. "“Gray Zone” Constitutionalism and the Dilemma of Judicial Independence in Pakistan" Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 46 (1): 1- 96.
Khan, Hamid. 1997. "Judicial appointments in the perspective of Independence of Judiciary" Pakistan Law Journal: 177.
Khan, Hamid. 1999. The Judicial Organ. Lahore: Freedom Forum for Human Rights and Development.
Khan, Hamid. 2009. Constitutional and Political History of Pakistan. 2nd ed. USA: Oxford University Press.
Khan, Hamid. "Role of Independent Judiciary in Countries of South Asia, Particularly Pakistan" <http://www.supremecourt.gov.pk/ijc/Articles/2/3.pdf>.
Khan, Hamid. "Struggle of the Constitutional Court in Pakistan for judicial independence". <http://ebookbrowse.com/struggle-of-the-constitutional-court-in-pakistan-for-judicial-independence-hamid-khan-pdf-d180137522>.
Khan, Masood and Niaz A. Shah. 2003. ‘Judicial Appointments in Pakistan’ Institute of Governance Public Policy and Social Research Queen’s University Belfast, Working Paper QU/GOV/5/2003.
LaPorte Jr, Robert. 1997. "Pakistan in 1996: starting over again." Asian Survey 37 (2): 118-125.
Lee, Hoong Phun. 2010. "Judiciaries in Crisis—Some Comparative Perspectives." Federal Law Review 38 (3): 371-389.
Legg, Thomas. 2001. "Judges for the new century." Public law 1: 62-76.
Legg, Thomas. 2004. "Brave New World—The New Supreme Court and Judicial Appointments." Legal Studies 24 (1‐2): 45-54.
Lunn, Jon and Gavin Thompson. 2012. Pakistan in 2013. Research Paper 12/76, House of Commons Library. .
Madison, James. The Federalist No 51, <https://www.csus.edu/indiv/f/friedman/fa2019/govt1/schedule/B/FED%2051.pdf>.
Malik, Hasnaat. 2013. "‘Ineffective’ Role in Appointment of Judges to Superior Courts: Parliamentary Committee Invites Lawyers for Consultations." Daily Times, December 23.
Malleson, Kate. 2004. "Creating a judicial appointments commission: which model works best?." Public Law 1: 102-121.
Mehmood, Sultan. 2020. "Judicial Independence and Development: Evidence from Pakistan." halshs-03054106. <https://halshs.archives-ouvertes.fr/halshs-03054106>.
Mehsood, Mobina, Fawad Khan, and Raza Ullah Shah. 2017. "Analysis of the Independence of Superior Judiciary Under Civilian Governments in Pakistan: From 1947 till 2009." Global Educations Studies Review 2 (1): 25-31.
Mian, Ajmal. 2004. A Judge Speaks Out. New York: Oxford University Press.
Mullally, Siobhan. 2009. "A Long March to Justice: A Report on Judicial Independence and Integrity in Pakistan." International Bar Association, Human Rights Institute.
Nadeem Ahmad v Federation of Pakistan, PLD 2010 SC 1165.
Naqvi, Faisal H. 2011. "Protecting the Independence of the Judiciary-I" The Express Tribune, March 13.
Nelson, Matthew J. 2018. "Indian Basic Model Jurisprudence in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan: Reconfiguring the Constitutional Politics of Religion." Asian Journal of Comparative Law 13 (2): 333-357.
Noorani, A. G. 2012. "Judicial Appointment or Judicial Incest?" Criterion Quarterly 6(2). <http://www.criterion-quarterly.com/judicial-appointment-or-judicial-incest/>.
Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights in Cooperation with the International Bar Association. 2003. Human Rights in the Administration of Justice: A Manual on Human Rights for Judges, Prosecutors and Lawyers, United Nations, Professional Training Series No 9 <http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/training9Titleen.pdf>.
Oral application by appellant in Dato’ Seri Anwar Bin Ibrahim v Public Prosecutor  CLJ 570.
Peri, Antonina. 2012. "Judicial independence vs. judicial accountability. Judicial selection models for Constitutional Courts. A comparative analysis" Comparative Law Review 3(1): 1-30.
Phillips, Lord. 2011. "Judicial independence and accountability: a view from the Supreme Court." Lecture delivered at the UCL Constitution Unit, launch of Research Project on The Politics of Judicial Independence 8.
Report on the ICJ Mission to Pakistan. Autumn 2011. <https://www.icj.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/06/Pakistan-ICJ-mission-fact-finding-mission-report-2012.pdf>.
Rizvi, Hassan Askari. 2010. "Analysis: Amending the constitution" Daily Times, April 11.
Rizvi, Syed Shabbar Raza. 2005. Constitutional Law of Pakistan: Text, Case Law and Analytical Commentary. 2nd ed. Lahore: Vanguard.
Roth, Lenny. 2012. Judicial Appointments. NSW Parliamentary Library Research Service, Briefing Paper No 3/2012.
Sackvill, R. 2008. "Three issues facing the Australian judiciary" Judicial Officer's Bulletin 20(3): 17.
Seervai, H. M. 2015. Constitutional Law of India. 4th ed. Gurgaon. University Law Publishing.
Shah, Amanullah and Bahadar Shah. 2008. "STUDY OF THE JUDICIAL APPOINTMENT IN PAKISTAN." Gomal University Journal of Research 24 (1): 181-188.
Shah, Amanullah. 2009. "STUDY OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL INDEPENDENCE OF THE SUPERIOR JUDICIARY IN PAKISTAN." Gomal University Journal of Research 25 (2): 1-10.
Shetreet, Shimon. 1987. "Who will judge: Reflections on the Process and Standards of Judicial Selection." Australian Law Journal 61(12): 766- 778.
Siddique, Osama. 2011. Approaches to Legal and Judicial Reform in Pakistan: Post Colonial Inertia and the Paucity of Imagination in Times of Turmoil and Change, DPRC Working Paper 4 <http://www.lprn.org.pk/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/DPRC-WP4-Siddique.pdf>.
Stevens, Robert. 2004. "Reform in haste and repent at leisure: lolanthe, the Lord High Executioner and Brave New World." Legal Studies 24 (1‐2): 1-34.
Supreme Court Advocates - on - Record Association v Union of India, (1993) 4 SCC 441.
The 19th IBA Biennial Conference, New Delhi, 22 October 1982.
UNODC (United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime). 2006. Access to Justice: The Independence, Impartiality and Integrity of the Judiciary. Criminal Justice Assessment Toolkit. <http://polis.osce.org/library/f/2700/531/UN-AUS-RPT-2700-EN-531>.
Wallace, J. Clifford. 2001. "An essay on independence of the judiciary: Independence from what and why." NYU Annual Survey of American Law 58: 241.
Waseem, Mohammad. 2012. "Judging democracy in Pakistan: Conflict between the executive and judiciary." Contemporary South Asia 20 (1): 19-31.
Williams, George, and Rachel Davis. 2003. "Reform of the judicial appointments process: gender and the bench of the High Court of Australia." Melbourne University Law Review 27 (3): 819.
Winterton, George. 1987. "Appointment of federal judges in Australia." Melbourne University Law Review 16: 185.
Yap, Po Jen, and Rehan Abeyratne. 2020. "Judicial Self-Dealing and Unconstitutional Constitutional Amendments in South Asia." International Journal of Constitutional Law July 27 (I-CON) (2021, Forthcoming), Available at SSRN. <https://ssrn.com/abstract=3661026>.
Copyright (c) 2021 Rao Imran Habib
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
CSRC Publishing and ROPE adhere to Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 4.0 International License. The authors, submitting and publishing in the journal Review of Politics and Public Policy in Emerging Economies published by CSRC Publishing, retain the copyright of their work and give the journal right to publish their work agreeing to the licensing policy under Creative Common Attribution-Non Commercial (NC-BY-NC 4.0) International. Under this license, the published authors let others remix, tweak, and build upon their work non-commercially. Yet all the other authors using the content of CSRC Publishing are required to cite author(s), journal name and publisher in their work.